I managed to find time in the afteroon to get back to the topic.
The starting point is March 2009 at which the global
equities bottomed out. Here are the accumulated returns, up to today (09/08/12),
for each of S&P 500 (SPX), DJ STOXX Europe 600 (SXXP), DJ Euro STOXX 600
(SXXE)[1] in
its respective currency.
Total Return
31/03/09 to 09/08/12
|
vs SPX
|
|
SPX
|
78%
|
--
|
SXXP
|
59%
|
-19%
|
SXXE
|
39%
|
-39%
|
Should Financials/Banks/Insurances/Real Estates be excluded,
Total Return
31/03/09 to 09/08/12
|
vs SPX ex Fin
|
|
SPX ex Fin
|
82%
|
--
|
SXXP ex Fin
|
70%
|
-13%
|
SXXE ex Fin
|
47%
|
-35%
|
It is clear
- Financials/Banks/Insurances/Real Estates played a significant part in Europe’s under-performance vs the US
- Eurozone is more stressed.
The relative performance shown above hasn’t yet answered the
question – Is Europe valuation distressed?
I tried a few methods to come up a straightforward yes-or-no
but to no avail. The main problem is the availability of good-quality data (or
lack of them rather). Most European countries’ pre-2000 data are hard to come
by. Key series, such as profit margins and revenue growth, are
non-existent.
An alternative way is to use Bob Shiller’s S&P CAPEdata. Assuming both US and Europe markets were
valued around the same magnitude,
SPX
|
Shiller’s CAPE
|
|
31/03/2009
|
787.5
|
13.32x
|
09/08/2012
|
1,400
|
21.76x
|
Post-war Average
|
18.3x
|
|
Post war, excl Jan 1998 to Dec 2007, Average
|
16.1x
|
|
Jan 1982 till now, Average[2]
|
22.0x
|
My personal comfort level for S&P 500 is around 18x for CAPE. To put in another way, today’s S&P is about 20%
over-bought. This means
- Non-Euro developed Europe is probably fairly valued
- Euro 12 countries are under-valued somewhere 15%-20%. More so with S Europe countries but less so with N Europe.
You may have noticed, in reaching these conclusions, I have
implicitly assumed that no permanent damage had been done to the capital/human stock in
Europe/Eurozone since 2008. This may turn out a big ask.
Update on 13/08
Update on 13/08
A recent commentary, When Bad Things Happen to Cheap Assets, by Ben Inker of GMO, also touched on the "cheapness" of European equities.
[1] STOXX Europe 600 (SXXP)
covers developed European markets including none-eurozone countries, whilst
EURO STOXX (SXXE) is limited to the 12 Eurozone countries.
[2] Burton Malkiel called it “Age
of Exuberance”…


No comments:
Post a Comment