Wednesday, 8 August 2012

Is Fraser & Neave Ltd (FNN) still a buy?


Some background info:

This is the latest episode of the land-grabbing among major breweries (see here and here).

It started with Thai Beverage and Kirin’s stake-building in Fraser & Neave Ltd (FNN), a Singapore conglomerate which also holds 39.70% -- 7.3% direct and 32.4% indrect via Asia Pacific Investment Ptd Ltd (APIPL), a JV between FNN and Heineken --  in Asia Pacific Brewery (APB).

Heineken’s hands were forced. On 20/07, it offered to pay S$50 per APB share to purchase the 39.70% APB stake from FNN plus S$163mn for Non-APB assets held by APIPL.

On 07/08, Kindest Place Group, an affiliate of Thai Beverage, counter-offered $55 per share for FNN’s 7.3% direct stake in APB.             

…

I did a quick sum-of-parts based on what I gather from FNN’s 31/03/12 quarterly report.
 S$mn
Frasers Commercial Trust (FCOT, SGX listed REIT, 23.20% owned) 
172
Frasers Centrepoint Trust (FCT, SGX listed REIT, 42.70% owned) [1]          
631
FCOT convertible perpetual units                                                                   
343
Investment properties (based on 31/03/12 quarterly)                                     
2,736
Development properties (based on 31/03/12 quarterly)                                  
4,427
Total, property portfolio                                                                                 
8,309

APB stake, based on latest S$55 offer[2][3]                                                        
5,638
Non-APB assets held by APIPL valued by Heineken[4]                                 
163

Fully consolidated soft drink and dairy business (i.e. 56.3% owned Fraser & Neave Holdings Bhd and 100% non-listed Singapore Softdrink units)
            o/w Soft drink (rolling 12m ebit $35, 16x[5])                                       
560
            o/w Dairy (rolling 12m ebit S$37, 12x)                                              
444

Vietnam Diary (listed, 9.50% owned, market value)                                     
321
Myanmar Brewery (55% owned by FNN, not part of APB/APIPL portfolio, estimate)
430

Times publishing unit (rolling 12m ebit S$28mn, 4.5x[6])                                
126
Total, non-property portfolio                                                                           
7,682
Net debt                                                                                                          
2,640

Thereof, NAV                                                                                                
S$13,351

Number of FNN shares                                                          
1,420.5

NAV per share                                                                                                 
S$9.40

FNN 08/08/12 close price                                                                               
S$8.49

i.e. a 11% discount

Here is a look-across to Singapore Press Holdings Ltd (SPH), a conglomerate with a significant investment property portfolio.

Media & publishing business (Rolling 12m ebit S$1052, 4.5x)                     
4,734
Investment Properties (Market value, based on 30/05/12quarterly)             
2,674

Net Debt                                                                                                        
252
Thereof, NAV                                                                                                 
7,156

Number of SPH shares                                                          
1,595.5

NAV per share                                                                                                 
S$4.49

SPH 08/08/12 close price                                                                               
S$4.03

This also translates to a 10% discount.

10% doesn’t appear much, after allowing for some holding company discount. But if you bet on a bidding war for the APB stake and some latentinterests in FNN’s soft drink franchise, there may be still something left on the table. A word of caution, though, SoTP is a “bull-market” valuation method.





[1] FNN’s property arm acts as the manager for the two REITs. The annual management fees, combined, amount to around S$20mn. Presumably, FNN would lose the management fee stream should it dispose of the two REITS.
[2] Heineken will have to at least match the S$55 price for the FNN board has to put the offers to shareholders for a vote.
[3] APB is fully consolidated to FNN. It is almost debt free (about S$120 mn net debt as of 31 March 2012), thus no adjustment for debt in the above calculation
[4] Arguably, Heineken will have to pay more after the S$55 per share counter-bid from the Kindest Place Group
[5] Earnings are adjusted for the minority leakage in Fraser & Neave Holdings Bhd. A take-out multiple will be much higher. FNN until 30/09/11 was the Coca-Cola bottler in Singapore/Malaysia.
[6] A relatively conservative multiple.

No comments:

Post a Comment